Back

Plantar Fasciitis: What You’ve Been Told, What You’ve Felt, and What Actually Works

Foot Pain·Nikki Beard·May 12, 2025· 8 minutes

Plantar fasciitis is one of the most common causes of heel pain, yet it’s often misunderstood and mistreated. You don’t need to be a runner or an athlete to develop it. In fact, it’s frequently seen in busy professionals, peri-menopausal women, and anyone who spends long periods on their feet or in restrictive, non-functional shoes. If you’re waking up with stabbing heel pain or limping after rest, this blog is for you.

What makes plantar fasciitis tricky is that the pain is usually the last thing to show up. The dysfunction starts earlier, often in the way the foot moves, grips, or compensates. Most people instinctively change how they stand or walk long before they realise something is wrong.

What Causes It? (And What Doesn’t)

Plantar fasciitis is an overuse injury of the plantar fascia, a band of connective tissue running from the heel to the toes. But it rarely acts alone. The underlying cause is usually poor foot mechanics, weak intrinsic muscles, restricted ankle mobility, and a long history of footwear that stops the foot from doing its job.

Most modern shoes overprotect or overcorrect the foot. Over time, this leads to deconditioning. When people switch to more minimal footwear without retraining the foot, it can feel like the shoes caused the problem—but it’s the years of underuse that created the weakness.

Despite popular belief, it’s not just a heel issue. The fascia is responding to a bigger problem. Resting might reduce pain, but it won’t fix faulty mechanics or strengthen the foot. Ice and insoles may offer temporary relief, but they do not build resilience. Without restoring how the foot actually functions, the problem continues under the surface.

Research shows that long-term solutions require restoring mobility, strength, and coordination across the foot and ankle, not just treating inflammation (Hedrick, 1996; NASM, 2020).

The Warning Signs You’re Heading That Way

One of the first clues that plantar fasciitis is brewing is that early morning pain in the heel, the kind that eases once you’ve pottered around the kitchen for ten minutes. You might notice discomfort after long periods of sitting or standing, especially if it takes a few steps to “walk it off.”

Many people begin avoiding barefoot walking altogether, instinctively protecting their feet without even realising it. Another subtle sign is an increasing reliance on structured shoes or arch supports because anything less feels unstable or uncomfortable. Some people begin toe-gripping just to feel steady. Others start favouring one leg over the other when standing. These are all signs the feet are overcompensating and under-functioning.

Why Mainstream Advice Often Misses the Mark

Most general advice for plantar fasciitis revolves around rest, ice, and stretching, but these approaches treat the symptoms, not the cause. The plantar fascia is rarely the true culprit. It becomes irritated because the foot is weak, under-active, or compensating for other issues like tight calves or stiff ankles.

Rest might offer temporary relief, but it doesn’t fix poor mechanics. Ice can numb the discomfort, but it won’t build strength. And stretching? That can often do more harm than good, especially if the fascia is already overstretched and inflamed, or the stretch is carried out with incorrect technique.

Rolling a frozen water bottle might feel helpful, but it won’t change how your foot loads with every step. Orthotics might prop up the arch temporarily, but long-term use can reduce muscle activity in the foot and make it weaker over time (Earls and Myers, 2017). Supportive shoes might feel comfortable, but if they remove the need for the foot to stabilise and adapt, they contribute to the problem.

This is why so many people find that the moment they stop wearing their insoles, the pain returns. The support never changed the way their foot actually works.

True recovery comes from strengthening, loading, and restoring natural function to the foot… from the feet up.

Preventive Strategies That Work

Prevention starts by building strength in the intrinsic muscles of the feet, something most people have never actively trained. Exercises like short foot drills and big toe lifts can help restore control and resilience where it matters most.

But it's not just about the foot. Calf mobility, ankle freedom, and the ability to connect your feet with your glutes are just as crucial. Without that connection, the load shifts upwards and shows up as knee or hip discomfort before the heel pain even begins.

Shoes play a big part too, but not in the way most people think. Flip flops and backless slippers often encourage toe gripping if the foot isn’t strong enough to control the movement. Heavily cushioned trainers or rigid soles remove the need for the foot to stabilise and adapt. Both ends of the spectrum can contribute to dysfunction, especially when the foot lacks strength. The goal isn’t more support. It’s more function.

Fascia responds best to gradual, consistent loading combined with mobility work and improved alignment strategies. Regular foot-focused movement helps maintain both strength and sensory feedback (Page, Frank and Lardner, 2010).

Finally, we have to shift the mindset from “exercise” to “daily movement.” Fascia thrives on gentle, regular movement, not occasional high-intensity workouts. A ten-minute daily routine focused on foot mobility and balance often does more good than an hour at the gym once a week.

If You’re Already Struggling… Here’s What Helps

If plantar fasciitis has already taken hold, the first step is to stop doing the wrong things. Aggressive stretching of the calves or plantar surface might seem helpful, but often does more harm than good, especially if the tissue is already irritated. Rest alone won’t cut it either. Fascia doesn’t just need a break; it needs the right kind of load to heal.

This is where hands-on therapy comes in. Targeted release work for the fascia, calves, and glutes can reduce tension and improve mobility, but it must be followed by progressive strengthening. Slowly reintroducing controlled load helps the fascia adapt and become more resilient.

Emotional stress should also be considered. It often shows up in the body, especially in the feet. During periods of hormonal change or overwhelm, the nervous system stays on alert, and this can increase muscular tension and reduce recovery capacity. For women in midlife, this is especially common.

Treatment Options: From Professional to DIY

If your pain lasts more than a few weeks or starts to change the way you move, it’s time to seek help. A proper therapist won’t just look at the painful area, they’ll assess your gait, your foot strength, and how your body moves as a whole.

Manual therapy, such as sports massage or hands-on foot treatment, can be incredibly effective in reducing tightness and improving alignment. But that’s only part of the picture. True healing also requires a shift in how you move. It means moving beyond quick fixes like rolling a tennis ball and instead learning how to engage your foot muscles properly.

Loading the tissue in a supported way helps the fascia remodel and heal. That includes barefoot mobility work, foot strengthening, and improving your walking mechanics. The more consistently you move well, the more likely your fascia is to recover.

Long-Term Management and Recovery

Fascia heals slowly. That means consistency matters more than intensity. You won’t solve this in a week, but that doesn’t mean progress is slow. The pain often begins to ease quickly when the right foundations are in place.

Strength work for the feet should remain part of your weekly routine, even once the discomfort is gone. It’s also worth staying mindful of your footwear choices and how you load your feet day to day. This is about building resilience, not just avoiding re-injury.

For long-term results, you need more than a fix. You need a strategy. One that respects how the foot functions as part of the whole body, and treats it as the starting point for recovery, not the afterthought.

Plantar fasciitis doesn’t need to define how you move, walk, or live. With the right support, education, and a foot-first approach, you can move out of pain and back into confidence. It might be a long game, but it’s a powerful one. You don’t need to settle for managing symptoms. You can change the root cause, and it starts …from the feet up.

References

Earls, J. and Myers, T. (2017) Fascial Release for Structural Balance. Revised ed. Chichester: Lotus Publishing.
Hedrick, A. (1996) ‘The plantar fascia’, Strength and Conditioning Journal, 18(5), pp. 7–10.
National Academy of Sports Medicine (2020) NASM Essentials of Corrective Exercise Training. 2nd ed. Edited by R. Fahmy. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Page, P., Frank, C. and Lardner, R. (2010) Assessment and Treatment of Muscle Imbalance: The Janda Approach. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.